Skip to main content

Go to accessibility options

1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 PSA Mint 9 - Pop One, None Higher! ...

1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 PSA Mint 9 - Pop One, None Higher! ...

Auction amount: $16,200.00

Sold: Dec 13, 2020

Pie Traynor

Baseball

Explore Pie Traynor Collectibles for Sale and Auction Results

Discover the real-world value of Pie Traynor trading cards, game-used equipment, and autographed memorabilia by browsing our realized-price archive. Whether you're buying, selling, or simply researching, recent auction results reveal exactly what collectors are paying for authenticated Pie Traynor pieces across eras, grades, and conditions. You can also place bids, make offers, or browse sought-after sports items currently available for purchase.

Heritage Auctions, the world's largest collectibles auctioneer, is the premier destination for sports memorabilia. Our specialists bring deep knowledge and passion to every item from jerseys to trading cards, helping collectors appreciate their significance and, as the best place to sell sports memorabilia, helping sellers achieve top-market prices.

1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 PSA Mint 9 - Pop One, None Higher!
Auction 50031 | Lot: 57354 | Dec 13, 2020

Sold For: $16,200.00
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball, PSA/DNA EX-MT+ 6.5.
Auction 50052 | Lot: 80474 | Feb 27, 2022

Sold For: $8,700.00

Make Offer to Owner
$13,050 or more
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 PSA NM-MT 8.
Auction 50030 | Lot: 53489 | Sep 10, 2020

Sold For: $8,100.00
1925-28 Pie Traynor Game Used Bat, PSA/DNA GU 7.
Auction 50059 | Lot: 57292 | Nov 19, 2022

Sold For: $8,100.00
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only One Higher.
Auction 50020 | Lot: 50615 | Dec 7, 2019

Sold For: $8,100.00
1926-34 Pie Traynor Game Used Bat, Graded "7" by PSA/DNA & MEARS.
Auction 7065 | Lot: 81466 | Oct 27, 2012

Sold For: $7,946.75

Make Offer to Owner
$12,516 or more
1926 Pie Traynor All America Team Certificate Signed by Babe Ruth. Could there be any greater honor for a Golden Age ballplayer than to be recognized by the legendary Babe Ruth as the best at your position? Surely Hall of Fame Pittsburgh Pirates third baseman Harold "Pie" Traynor was suitably honored by the presentation of this elegant scroll naming him as the cream of the 1926 crop. While these certificates do occasionally surface in the hobby, the Cooperstown credentials of the recipient in this case adds particular appeal. Signing off on the Babe's choice is a committee of sportswriters from each Big League city, with the tremendously desirable "Geo. H. 'Babe' Ruth" signature variation at bottom worth the price of admission alone. All autographs present at a strength of 9/10 or better, and the certificate itself offers no condition flaws to note. Measures 13x18" in size, with matting and framing extending the final dimensions to 17x25". Certificate was gifted to actor Max Gail, who appeared in the title role of the 1984 Broadway production "The Babe." A signed Playbill and poster from this production is included. LOA from PSA/DNA. LOA from James Spence Authentication.
Auction 707 | Lot: 19093 | May 5, 2007

Sold For: $7,170.00
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only One Higher.
Auction 50009 | Lot: 50022 | Jan 24, 2019

Sold For: $6,600.00
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 PSA NM-MT 8.
Auction 7138 | Lot: 80022 | Apr 14, 2016

Sold For: $5,497.00
1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 SGC 96 Mint 9 - The Only Delong Graded Mint by SGC!
Auction 7041 | Lot: 80105 | Nov 11, 2011

Sold For: $5,078.75
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball, JSA/Beckett Gem Mint 10.

Auction 50001 | Lot: 80397 | Feb 25, 2018

Sold For: $5,040.00
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 SGC NM/MT 8.
Auction 50049 | Lot: 56346 | Nov 20, 2021

Sold For: $4,920.00
1934-36 Batter-Up (R318) Pie Traynor #14 PSA NM-MT 8. Offered is one of only two PSA NM-MT examples, with not one having attained a higher grade. It is not too often you see these cards without the little creasing around the perforations. This is an outstanding specimen with virtually no wear at all, the perforations strongly intact and amazingly sharp corners for an issue that is notorious for corner wear problems.
Auction 9709 | Lot: 19096 | May 2, 2008

Sold For: $4,481.25
1920's Baseball Autograph Book Signed by Ruth, Gehrig & More. Charming little book was once the proud possession of a young baseball and ham radio enthusiast in the later years of the 1920's. In a childlike hand he lists all of the stations he has been able to tune in, and a modified box score for a 1927 Red Sox vs. Yankees game he heard on his radio. The opening three pages of the book, however, document a close encounter with many of the stars he followed on the airwaves. Most notable are 10/10 pencil signatures from Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, though the first page boasts a tremendous gathering of ink signatures including Dave Bancroft, Pie Traynor, Ki Ki Cuyler and Joe Cronin. The spine of the small leatherbound volume has loosened over time but the pages still remain attached, and while there is toning at the outer edges the autographs themselves are not materially affected. An embodiment of the age of innocence and wonder that was Golden Age baseball. LOA from PSA/DNA.
Auction 704 | Lot: 19053 | May 6, 2006

Sold For: $4,481.25
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 7032 | Lot: 80608 | Apr 22, 2011

Sold For: $4,182.50
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only One Higher.
Auction 7225 | Lot: 50022 | Sep 21, 2017

Sold For: $3,999.60
1956-57 Rogers Hornsby, Pie Traynor & Other Hall of Famers Multi-Signed Baseball.
Auction 50029 | Lot: 80365 | Aug 30, 2020

Sold For: $3,960.00
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 7028 | Lot: 80819 | Nov 5, 2010

Sold For: $3,346.00
Amazing 1930's Child's Autograph Scrapbook with Rare Hall of Fame Signatures Franklin Young, the boy who compiled this wonderful assortment of newspaper clippings and flawless ink signatures, obviously took this hobby very seriously. The newspaper photographs and articles are cut with military precision, glued careful to the pages without the slightest crooked angle. And he chose his subjects well. Though there are obvious sentimental favorites, and the book tends toward the Pittsburgh Pirates, he is sure to include the men who were making the biggest noise in the sports pages as well, offering some of the finest vintage signatures from the Hall of Famers of the day that we've seen. Well over 125 autographs are compiled in this thrilling volume, and while many of the pages have come loose from the bindings, and are often chipping at the edges, not a single autograph is adversely affected. Occasionally the boy had the ballplayers sign the newspaper clipping itself, and other times they would sign the page beside the clipping instead. For description's sake, we will note (clip) beside the autographs that are on the newspaper image itself. Highlights include: Rogers Hornsby (2), Orel Hildebrand, Jim Bottomley, Rogers Hornsby (clip), Charlie Grimm (2), Augie Galan (2), Charlie Root, Tony Lazzeri, Gabby Hartnett, Lon Warneke, Pie Traynor (3), Arky Vaughan (clip, 2), Cookie Lavagetto, Grimm/Hartnett/Root together below a photo of all three, Honus Wagner (amazing, huge and perfect signature!), Waite Hoyt (edge wear barely touches unpersonalized inscription), Paul Waner, Cookie Lavagetto (clip), Fred Schulte, Paul Waner (clip), Monty Stratton, Ted Lyons, Jimmie Dykes, Dizzy Dean and Paul Dean side by side, scorecard signed by Jimmie Dykes, Luke Sewell and three more White Sox. Each autograph in the book is accompanied by its own, separate Global certificate of authenticity, so breakdown possibilities are tremendous. An amazing opportunity for both dealers and collectors. LOA from PSA/DNA.
Auction 704 | Lot: 19061 | May 6, 2006

Sold For: $3,107.00
Amazing 1930's Child's Autograph Scrapbook with Rare Hall of Fame Signatures Franklin Young, the boy who compiled this wonderful assortment of newspaper clippings and flawless ink signatures, obviously took this hobby very seriously. The newspaper photographs and articles are cut with military precision, glued careful to the pages without the slightest crooked angle. And he chose his subjects well. Though there are obvious sentimental favorites, and the book tends toward the Pittsburgh Pirates, he is sure to include the men who were making the biggest noise in the sports pages as well, offering some of the finest vintage signatures from the Hall of Famers of the day that we've seen. Well over 125 autographs are compiled in this thrilling volume, and while many of the pages have come loose from the bindings, and are often chipping at the edges, not a single autograph is adversely affected. Occasionally the boy had the ballplayers sign the newspaper clipping itself, and other times they would sign the page beside the clipping instead. For description's sake, we will note (clip) beside the autographs that are on the newspaper image itself. Highlights include: Rogers Hornsby (2), Orel Hildebrand, Jim Bottomley, Rogers Hornsby (clip), Charlie Grimm (2), Augie Galan (2), Charlie Root, Tony Lazzeri, Gabby Hartnett, Lon Warneke, Pie Traynor (3), Arky Vaughan (clip, 2), Cookie Lavagetto, Grimm/Hartnett/Root together below a photo of all three, Honus Wagner (amazing, huge and perfect signature!), Waite Hoyt (edge wear barely touches unpersonalized inscription), Paul Waner, Cookie Lavagetto (clip), Fred Schulte, Paul Waner (clip), Monty Stratton, Ted Lyons, Jimmie Dykes, Dizzy Dean and Paul Dean side by side, scorecard signed by Jimmie Dykes, Luke Sewell and three more White Sox. Each autograph in the book is accompanied by its own, separate Global certificate of authenticity, so breakdown possibilities are tremendous. An amazing opportunity for both dealers and collectors. LOAs from James Spenc
Auction 701 | Lot: 19178 | Sep 11, 2004

Sold For: $3,107.00
1960's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball. Here's a single most Hall of Fame collections are missing, an exceptionally rare specimen from the seventeen-year veteran of Forbes Field's hot corner. The 1948 Hall of Fame inductee has penned a perfect blue felt tip autograph high on the side panel of a "Mel Stottlemyre Special League" ball for a fan. The ball itself remains in wonderful condition, with no issues of toning or foxing whatsoever. LOA from Steve Grad & Zach Rullo/ PSA DNA.
Auction 702 | Lot: 19022 | May 14, 2005

Sold For: $2,987.50
Signed 1927 Exhibits Pie Traynor PSA Authentic, PSA/DNA Auto 10.
Auction 60024 | Lot: 53534 | Sep 30, 2022

Sold For: $2,760.00
1960's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 7150 | Lot: 12813 | Nov 7, 2015

Sold For: $2,629.00

Make Offer to Owner
$3,944 or more
1960's Max Carey Single Signed Baseball. The finest defensive center fielder in the National League during his prime, "Scoops" also topped the charts in stolen bases ten times and retired as the most prolific base thief in League history. His career with the Pittsburgh Pirates spanned the days of Honus Wagner and Fred Clarke to the emergence of Pie Traynor and Paul Waner. Here he appears on the sweet spot of a baseball stamped with the words "Baseball Hall of Fame," offering a bold blue ink signature that competes exceedingly well with the rare few singles we've encountered in the past. A thin coat of shellac has been brushed over the autograph, toning only a fraction of a shade, while a scuff to the panel directly over the sweet spot does not affect the fine autograph in the slightest. LOA from Steve Grad & Zach Rullo/ PSA DNA.
Auction 702 | Lot: 19021 | May 14, 2005

Sold For: $2,629.00
1934-36 Diamond Stars Pie Traynor #99 PSA NM-MT 8 - Pop Four, None Higher.
Auction 50054 | Lot: 50599 | May 14, 2022

Sold For: $2,400.00

Make Offer to Owner
$3,600 or more
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball, PSA/DNA NM+ 7.5.
Auction 7085 | Lot: 81632 | Nov 9, 2013

Sold For: $2,390.00
1940 Play Ball SGC-Graded Collection (11). High grade examples, all featuring Hall of Fame members and a couple of high-numbered cards to boot. Includes SGC 88 NM/MT 8: 2 cards w/#'s 134 Joe Cronin and 224 Pie Traynor; SGC 86 NM+ 7.5: 2 cards w/#'s 132 Connie Mack and 168 Honus Wagner; SGC 84 NM 7: 5 cards w/#'s 88 Mel Ott, 171 Harry Heilmann, 174 Johnny Evers, 178 Max Carey and 180 Mickey Cochrane; SGC 80 EX/NM 6: 2 cards w/#'s 236 Jim Bottomley and 238 Tony Lazzeri.
Auction 9709 | Lot: 19105 | May 2, 2008

Sold For: $2,390.00
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball, PSA/DNA NM+ 7.5.
Auction 7051 | Lot: 81849 | May 5, 2012

Sold For: $2,390.00
1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 PSA EX 5.
Auction 50069 | Lot: 80467 | May 18, 2024

Sold For: $2,220.00

Make Offer to Owner
$3,330 or more
1934-36 Diamond Stars Pie Traynor #99 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only One Higher!
Auction 50030 | Lot: 53617 | Sep 10, 2020

Sold For: $2,220.00
Signed 1946-52 Pie Traynor Hall of Fame Plaque Postcard (Type 2) Pie PSA Authentic, PSA/DNA Auto 9 - Pop One, None Higher - From the Southside Bobby Collection.
Auction 50073 | Lot: 80987 | Dec 7, 2024

Sold For: $2,160.00

Make Offer to Owner
$3,240 or more
1967 Venezuela Topps Pie Traynor #144 PSA NM 7.
Auction 50065 | Lot: 80471 | Nov 18, 2023

Sold For: $1,920.00

Make Offer to Owner
$2,880 or more
1951 Pie Traynor "Baseball's Greatest Lineup" Presentational Certificate.
Auction 7041 | Lot: 80972 | Nov 11, 2011

Sold For: $1,912.00
1934-36 Diamond Stars Pie Traynor #99 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only One Higher.
Auction 50020 | Lot: 50787 | Dec 7, 2019

Sold For: $1,860.00
1950's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 50002 | Lot: 50038 | May 18, 2018

Sold For: $1,801.20

Make Offer to Owner
$2,702 or more
1968 Pittsburgh Pirates Team Signed Baseball with Pie Traynor.
Auction 50019 | Lot: 53975 | Oct 25, 2019

Sold For: $1,620.00
1935 Diamond Stars Pie Traynor #27 PSA NM-MT 8 - Only Two Higher.
Auction 50060 | Lot: 50235 | Jan 27, 2023

Sold For: $1,620.00
1928 Pie Traynor Original Charles Conlon Photograph Used for 1933 Goudey #22 Card.
Auction 7165 | Lot: 54438 | Nov 19, 2016

Sold For: $1,553.50
1960's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 7150 | Lot: 12814 | Nov 7, 2015

Sold For: $1,553.50
Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 49043 | Lot: 43046 | Apr 19, 2009

Sold For: $1,553.50
Circa 1909 Forbes Field Stadium Seat. Honus Wagner, Pie Traynor and Rabbit Maranville are among the many baseball luminaries to call Forbes Field home during the long service of this gorgeous seat from the defunct Pittsburgh ballpark. Remaining in highly desirable unrestored condition, this masterpiece in iron and wood is a marvel of early century design. It retains its final incarnation of green paint, which has given way to an appealing degree of oxidation on the figural sides and has peeled slightly from the slats of wood that make up the seating surface. A tiny and original number "15" plaque remains imbedded in the top slat. A tough and highly desirable specimen.
Auction 703 | Lot: 19538 | Oct 29, 2005

Sold For: $1,493.75
1933 Goudey Pie Traynor #22 SGC EX/NM 6.
Auction 50074 | Lot: 80182 | Oct 6, 2024

Sold For: $1,380.00

Make Offer to Owner
$2,070 or more
1938 Pittsburgh Pirates Team Signed Baseball with Honus Wagner. The man whose face appears on the hobby's most expensive trading card was a sixty-four year old coach for his former squad when he joined twenty-three fellow Bucs on the gently toned hide of this ONL (Frick) baseball. The Hall of Fame talent doesn't end with the Old Dutchman however, as Pie Traynor, Arky Vaughan and both Waner brothers up the ante even further. Condition is yet another feather in the black and gold cap, as the vintage blue ink averages an impressive 8/10. Mild age toning and the slightest effects of handling wear do nothing to diminish the impressive visual effect of this historic sphere. Only a single autograph, that of veteran pitcher Red Lucas, has been deemed to be secretarial. You'll be hard pressed to find a ball with more marquee names than the one you see here. LOA from PSA/DNA.
Auction 704 | Lot: 19391 | May 6, 2006

Sold For: $1,374.25
1939 Honus Wagner & Pie Traynor Signed Baseball Centennial First Day Cover.
Auction 50013 | Lot: 56198 | May 17, 2019

Sold For: $1,320.00
1933 Delong Pie Traynor #12 PSA NM-MT 8.
Auction 50012 | Lot: 51353 | Apr 19, 2019

Sold For: $1,320.00
1960's Pie Traynor Single Signed Baseball.
Auction 7032 | Lot: 80631 | Apr 22, 2011

Sold For: $1,314.50
1938 Pittsburgh Pirates Team Signed Baseball. An absolutely astounding array of Hall of Fame talent took the Bucs to the brink of N.L. Championship glory, though the hated Cubs nipped the Pirates at the wire to take the flag by a two-game margin. One look at this ONL (Frick) ball will leave you wondering how any team could possibly top this one, as we encounter coach Honus Wagner, manager Pie Traynor, both Waner brothers, Arky Vaughan, Heine Manush and many more. Twenty-six signatures are here in all, with the vast majority falling well within the realm of NRMT, with all listed notables among the strongest on the ball. Clearly one of the highest grade balls to surface from this power-packed team. LOA from PSA/DNA.
Auction 703 | Lot: 19382 | Oct 29, 2005

Sold For: $1,314.50
Pittsburgh Pirates Greats Multi-Signed Baseball with Honus Wagner. Fantastic vintage OAL (Harridge) baseball sports six signatures from the storied Pirates organization, with the highlight being a tremendous application that reads "J. Honus Wagner." Others here include Pie Traynor, Bud Hafey, and Fred Schulte. The clean ball displays the vintage cream tone associated with aging orbs. All sigs remain remarkably legible with no major condition issues to note. LOA from PSA/DNA.
Auction 47061 | Lot: 10409 | Jun 24, 2007

Sold For: $1,314.50

1

2 3 4 5

Results per page: 24 48 72

© 2025 Heritage Auctions | All Rights Reserved